Sparta: Super Or Not? (Monday, Mar 12)
I went to see the movie 300 this past weekend and it was enjoyable. Pretty much what I expected after seeing the previews: it looked just like a movie version of a Frank Miller graphic novel. In a good way, of course.
Since I know essentially nothing about "real" ancient history, I decided to check out the Wikipedia entry on Sparta to get an overview and I noticed that it was locked and under dispute:
Hmm, what's that all about? So I clicked through to the Talk:Sparta page and man o' man, what a grand Edit War they've got going on there. It's absolutely hilarious to a disinterested outsider like me. At this point in time (here's the permalink to a version of the page from today, in case it goes away or gets drastically changed) the big dispute is over whether Sparta should have been called a "superpower" or not, although there seems to be a lot of personality clash going on to fuel the fire.
If you've got a whole lot of time (more time than me, because I just did a healthy skim of the page), there's a world of entertainment buried in that discussion. To an oddball sense of humor like mine, anyway. Start at the Sparta as a World Power section about 1/4 of the way down the page and keep on reading.
It's also interesting to see how disputes like this get resolved in an open forum like Wikipedia. On the one hand, there's the idealist mindset of Do Not Feed The Trolls (DNFT), hoping that trollish behavior will eventually just go away. On the other hand, this sort of thing can end up being a huge timesink for the people who are the real caretakers in such a situation, and it's not necessarily clear whether there's true trolling going on here or not. It might just be an honest-to-goodness (and very harsh) disagreement.
[ permalink ] [ e-mail me ] [ read/add comments ]


In







